Skip to main content
ASCAMERICAN SHUTTERCOMPANY
Back to Blog

Shutter Painting and Refinishing: What You Need to Know

By American Shutter Company
Shutter Painting and Refinishing: What You Need to Know

Thinking about painting your plantation shutters to freshen them up or match new decor? Here's everything you need to know about painting and refinishing shutters successfully.

Can Plantation Shutters Be Painted?

Short answer: Yes, but it's more complex than painting a wall.

Long answer: Success depends on material, current finish, and proper preparation. Some shutters paint beautifully; others are nearly impossible to paint well.

Best Candidates for Painting

Wood Shutters

Paintability: Excellent Best approach: Professional spray painting for smooth factory finish DIY difficulty: High (brush marks show easily) Expected result: Can look factory-new with proper prep

Composite Shutters

Paintability: Good to Fair Best approach: Light sanding, primer, spray paint DIY difficulty: Very High (finish adheres poorly without proper prep) Expected result: Acceptable with professional application

Vinyl Shutters

Paintability: Poor Best approach: Specialized vinyl paint only DIY difficulty: Extremely High Expected result: Often disappointing; paint chips within 1-2 years

When NOT to Paint

Skip painting if:

  • Shutters are severely warped (paint won't fix structural issues)
  • Extensive water damage present (painting covers but doesn't solve)
  • Frame is rotting (needs replacement, not paint)
  • Current finish is peeling due to moisture (problem will return)

The Professional Painting Process

Step 1: Removal and Disassembly

Remove shutters from windows, remove all hardware, separate panels if needed

Step 2: Deep Cleaning

Remove all dust, grease, and grime that prevent paint adhesion

Step 3: Sanding

Light sanding to roughen surface and remove old finish inconsistencies

Step 4: Priming

Oil-based primer for wood; specialized primer for composite/vinyl

Step 5: Painting

Multiple thin coats of high-quality paint, allowing proper drying between coats

Step 6: Reassembly and Reinstallation

Reinstall hardware, hang shutters, ensure proper operation

DIY Painting: Honest Assessment

Challenges you'll face:

  • Getting into all louver angles
  • Avoiding brush marks and drips
  • Achieving consistent color
  • Preventing paint from gumming up moving parts
  • Matching factory-smooth finish

Time investment:

  • Small window (4 panels): 8-12 hours
  • Medium window (6 panels): 12-16 hours
  • Per window costs add up quickly

Common DIY mistakes:

  • Painting shutters while installed (paint drips, louvers stick)
  • Using wrong paint type (poor adhesion, yellowing)
  • Insufficient sanding (paint peels within months)
  • Too-thick coats (gummy louvers that won't tilt)

Cost Comparison

Professional painting per window:

  • Basic: $200-350
  • Complex/large: $350-500
  • Includes removal, prep, paint, reinstall

DIY costs per window:

  • Paint/primer: $40-60
  • Sandpaper/supplies: $20-30
  • Time: 8-16 hours
  • Risk of poor result: High

New shutters:

  • Per window: $300-800
  • Includes new hardware, warranty
  • 20+ year lifespan

Refinishing vs. Painting

Refinishing (removing old finish, applying new stain):

  • Only for real wood shutters
  • Expensive but beautiful results
  • Shows wood grain
  • Cost: $300-500 per window

Painting (covering with opaque color):

  • Works on wood and composite
  • More affordable
  • Hides imperfections
  • Cost: $200-350 per window

Color Considerations for Houston Homes

Best shutter colors for Houston climate:

  1. White (reflects heat, stays cooler)
  2. Off-white/cream (hides dust better than pure white)
  3. Light gray (modern, heat-reflective)

Avoid these in Houston:

  • Dark colors (absorb heat, warp faster)
  • Black (extreme heat buildup)
  • Bold colors (limit resale appeal)

When Replacement is Better Than Painting

Choose replacement over painting if:

  • Shutters are 15+ years old and showing wear
  • Multiple mechanical issues (not just cosmetic)
  • You want to change style or upgrade material
  • Painting cost approaches 70% of replacement cost

Our Recommendation

We're honest: sometimes painting isn't worth it. Before investing in painting:

  1. Assess structural condition
  2. Calculate cost vs. replacement
  3. Consider lifespan after painting (5-8 years typical)
  4. Factor in your time or professional costs

Need honest advice on paint vs. repair vs. replace? Call (281) 441-7998 for free assessment.